What did you think of last night's episode of American Idol?

Do you think American made the right choice by eliminated Alexis? How did you like the duet by Carrie Underwood and Randy Travis?

Here are what some Yahoo users are saying about this particular topic....


"I thought the duet was great! And I definitely am happy with America's choice! I have never, ever liked Alexis and I'm very pleased that she went home."

By: Blue Eyed Angel

"i wasnt pleased. but not super upset coz the ones i like are still in the competition.. i think the worst was michael.. she shouldnt leave.. bottom 2 maybe, but leaving? i find it so wrong.

the duet was awesome ! i think carrie was awesome and great."

By : Archie + Gossip girl!

"I was not happy with Alexis leaving the show. Last week, when they sang Michael Jackson songs, she had the best performance (IMHO), singing "Dirty Diana." She didn't do quite as well with her country song, but she was certainly not the worst. Sarver should've went home, not Alexis.

Carrie did most of the singing in the duet with Randy Travis, which I was happy about. I've never been much of a fan of Randy Travis anyways, but Carrie is awesome!"

By :Hoosier Daddy


"Heck no, America made a huge mistake. Alexis was one of the best. Michael should have gone home. He doesn't even get into his songs. He just stands up there and hardly moves.

The duet was ok. You could tell Randy hadn't sang live in a long time."

By :Jillian

"i was SHOCKED when alexis got into the bottom three, but i wasn't shocked to see her eliminated when she was up against michael sarver.
we all know this week alexis just wasn't her usual spectacular self (compare last week's dirty diana and this week's performance and you'll get what i mean) but i think most of us would agree that alexis has a world more of talent compared to michael sarver.

however, sarver's fan base is strong, consisting of people who would vote for him no matter how he is consistently average.he gets voters who like him because of the nice family guy he is, not necessarily because of his talent, or his performance each week.so knowing all that beforehand, i was very much prepared for ryan to say that alexis had the least number of votes.

as for carrie and randy, i thought it was pretty good!i don't really listen to country music, but i actually enjoyed the performance."

By :gutter_f...

"Alexis did have a great voice hands down! They are all very talented and amazing, OTHERWISE they wouldnt have made it this far! Someone has to go every week!!! So every week someone is going to complain because they are too good to leave! THEY ARE ALL GOOD PEOPLE!!!! And i'm sorry but Danny is going to win! :)

I loved Alexis at first and she seemed to really deserve to be the next American Idol... But in the last couple of episodes I have changed my mind... She got too cocky too fast. (Like Kayne West) She had no emotion ever, when Ryan asked her last night how emotional the show had been... you could tell nothing she said came from the heart, probably just a script she wrote. Go back and watch her addition, she was so sweet and spunky... and then the judges said she needed to change and she did. But she hasn't seemed very happy the last few weeks."

By :disclose...

"No, I think Alexis was the wrong choice. I think she has a lot of talent. I expected to see Michael Sarver go.

I'm not a country fan, but I did think the duet was very nice."

By :Shortie